Choosing the right roof for your home is a big decision; one that affects your comfort, safety, and budget for years to come. Have you thought recently about what’s protecting your home and everything inside it?
If you’re considering a new roof, you’ve probably come across two common options: metal roofing and asphalt shingles. Both are popular for good reasons, but they offer different benefits depending on your needs. It’s important to understand how each roofing type performs in your climate. It can feel like a lot to sort through, but getting clear on the facts can help you choose with confidence.
In this guide, we’ll walk you through an honest, side-by-side look at metal vs. shingle roofing. We’ll cover durability, cost, maintenance, appearance, and more, so you can decide what’s best for your home.
Metal Roofing vs Shingle Roofing: The Basics Explained
What Is Metal Roofing?
Metal roofing is a strong, low-maintenance option that’s growing in popularity for all home styles. Whether you choose stainless steel, aluminum, high-end copper, or zinc, metal roofs offer long-lasting protection with minimal upkeep.
Styles and Materials of Metal Roofing
Metal roofing comes in several distinct styles. Standing seam roofs feature clean, modern vertical lines and hidden fasteners, giving them a sleek appearance. Corrugated panels, often associated with barns or rustic homes, provide a more rugged aesthetic. Metal shingles and tiles are designed to mimic traditional roofing materials like asphalt, slate, or clay tile, offering a classic look with the durability of metal.
As for materials, steel is a strong, widely used option that’s typically galvanized to resist rust. Aluminum is lightweight and naturally rust-proof, making it ideal for coastal or humid climates. Copper and zinc are considered premium choices, prized for their exceptional longevity and unique patinas that develop over time.
Appearance and Common Myths
Today’s metal roofs are available in a wide range of colors and finishes, making them suitable for both modern and traditional home designs. Their versatility and strong curb appeal often surprise homeowners who assume metal roofs only suit industrial or rural looks.
Two common myths deserve clarification. First, noise: with proper decking and insulation, metal roofs are not significantly louder than shingle roofs during rain or hail. Second, rust: high-quality metal roofs are engineered to resist corrosion for decades, thanks to protective coatings and durable materials like galvanized steel or aluminum.
What Is Shingle Roofing?
Shingle roofing typically refers to asphalt shingles, the most widely used roofing material in the U.S. Known for their affordability and traditional appearance, they’re a common choice for homes across Ohio.
Styles and Materials of Asphalt Roofing
Asphalt shingles are made with either a fiberglass or organic base, coated in asphalt and mineral granules, and installed in overlapping rows to create a textured surface. There are three primary types: 3-tab shingles, which are flat and basic but less common today; architectural shingles, which are thicker, more durable, and offer a dimensional look; and luxury shingles, which are designed to mimic slate or wood, giving homes a high-end aesthetic.
Appearance
In terms of appearance, asphalt shingles are available in a wide range of colors and tones, allowing them to blend well with most architectural styles and neighborhood guidelines. Their textured surface also helps conceal minor imperfections on the roof.
While asphalt remains the dominant material, other types of shingles are also found, especially on historic or custom homes, including wood shakes, slate, and composite shingles. These alternatives offer distinct aesthetics but typically come with a higher price tag and require specialized installation.
Cost Comparison of Metal and Shingle Roofs in Sugarcreek, Ohio
One of the first questions homeowners ask is, “How much is this going to cost?” Roofing is a significant investment, so let’s talk about the costs. We’ll consider both the initial installation costs and the long-term costs. Prices can vary by region and home, but we’ll give ballpark figures and point out what might be true for Sugarcreek, Ohio, and nearby areas.
Initial Installation Costs
Asphalt shingles are much cheaper upfront than metal roofs, which is why most homes use them. Costs vary based on materials, including the highest quality shingles, roof complexity, and labor, but generally fall within most homeowners’ budgets. In areas like Sugarcreek, prices tend to reflect national trends.
Metal roofs are significantly more expensive. The higher cost comes from both the materials and the specialized labor required for installation. While the initial price can be surprising, many contractors, like Asbury Roofing & Siding in Sugarcreek, note that the longer lifespan and reduced maintenance often justify the investment over time.
Long-Term Maintenance and Repair Expenses
This is where the calculus can shift. A roof isn’t a set-and-forget part of your home, especially in a climate like Ohio, where we face all four seasons.
Metal Roof Maintenance
Metal roofing stands out as one of the lowest-maintenance roofing options available. Once installed, a quality metal roof needs very little attention over the years. It doesn’t rot, crack, or warp, and it naturally resists mold, mildew, and algae, issues that can plague other roofing materials. You won’t be dealing with curling shingles or shedding granules.
Upkeep is simple. Most of the time, it’s enough to occasionally rinse off leaves or debris and visually inspect areas like flashings and fasteners, especially on exposed-fastener systems. Some manufacturers recommend just an annual hose-down and a quick check to ensure sealants are still intact. Unless there’s external damage, like from a falling tree branch, repairs are rare. Metal roofs are built to be tough, and it’s not unusual for them to go decades without needing a single fix.
Shingle Roof Maintenance
Asphalt shingles, by contrast, tend to require more ongoing care and occasional repairs throughout their lifespan, potentially leading to expensive repairs. Over time, shingles can shed their protective granules due to sun exposure, rain, and snow. This gradual wear may lead to bald spots or fading, slightly affecting both performance and curb appeal.
In humid areas, algae growth is another common issue; those dark streaks you see on some roofs are usually caused by algae. Addressing it may involve gentle cleaning or the installation of zinc strips to prevent future buildup.
Lifespan and Replacement Cycle
In climates like Ohio, harsh weather can take a toll on roofing materials, especially asphalt shingles. Freeze-thaw cycles, heavy snow, hail, and strong winds all contribute to wear and tear. Even shingles rated for 25 or 30 years may fall short of that mark in practice. It’s not uncommon for homeowners in the region to need a replacement after just 18 to 20 years, particularly if severe storms have passed through. This makes shingles a more affordable choice upfront, but potentially a repeat expense down the road.
Metal roofs, on the other hand, offer significantly greater longevity, which helps offset their higher initial cost when considered over the life of the home. They also tend to boost resale value more than shingles, largely because buyers appreciate the peace of mind that comes with a long-lasting, low-maintenance roof.
To summarize the cost:
Durability and Lifespan Differences
When choosing a roof, longevity and resilience matter. This section answers two big questions: How long do metal roofs last? And how do they compare to shingles? It’s not just about years, it’s how well each roof holds up to weather, wear, and time.
How Long Do Metal Roofs Last?
One of metal roofing’s biggest advantages is its exceptional lifespan. A properly installed metal roof can be a better investment, lasting 40 to 70+ years, and in some cases, even over 100 years. Most homeowners won’t need to replace one in their lifetime.
Lifespan by Material
- Steel (Galvanized or Galvalume): Typically lasts 40–60 years. Painted finishes often come with 30–50-year warranties and can be refreshed later to extend life.
- Aluminum: Naturally rust-resistant and long-lasting, often 50+ years. Softer than steel but holds up well in wet climates.
- Copper: Premium option that can exceed 100 years. Extremely corrosion-resistant, seen on historic buildings from the 1800s.
- Zinc: Lasts 80–100 years and forms a patina that heals scratches. Used mostly in high-end architecture due to cost.
- Stone-Coated Steel: Offers the durability of steel with an added layer of stone for protection and aesthetics, typically rated for 50+ years.
How Long Do Shingle Roofs Last?
Asphalt shingle roofs typically last 20–25 years, though the range can vary from 15 to 30 years depending on materials, installation, and local conditions.
Key Factors That Affect Lifespan:
- Shingle Quality: Basic 3-tab shingles wear out sooner, while architectural asphalt shingles and designer shingles last longer, sometimes up to 30 years or more with ideal care.
- Climate: Midwest weather is tough on shingles. Sun, hail, wind, and ice can all accelerate wear. Poor insulation or ventilation can also lead to ice dams and damage.
- Ventilation: Proper attic ventilation prevents heat buildup that can age shingles prematurely.
- Wear Signs: Curling, missing shingles, granule loss, or exposed fiberglass mean it’s time to inspect or replace.
Comparing Lifespans: Metal vs. Shingle
A metal roof can easily outlast two or more shingle roofs. Over 50 years, you might replace asphalt shingles twice, while a well-installed metal roof could still be going strong.
If you’d rather not deal with roof replacements again, metal offers long-term peace of mind. But if you’re comfortable with a 20-year cycle or plan to move shortly, shingles can be a practical, budget-friendly choice.
For many homeowners, it comes down to how long you plan to stay. In a “forever home,” the longevity of metal may be worth the upfront cost. In a starter home, shingles may make more sense for now.
Energy Efficiency and Environmental Impact
Roofing isn’t just about keeping rain out; it also influences your home’s energy performance and has broader environmental implications. This section compares metal vs shingles in terms of energy efficiency (think attic temperatures, AC bills, etc.) and environmental impact (from production to disposal).
Metal Roofing and Energy Savings
Metal roofs are known for their energy efficiency, especially in hot climates. Many qualify as “cool roofs” because they reflect solar heat rather than absorb it. Coated metal surfaces can significantly lower attic temperatures—one study showed up to 40°F cooler under a white metal roof compared to dark shingles. This can translate to substantial savings on cooling costs.
Metal also cools off quickly after sunset thanks to high emissivity, reducing heat buildup into the evening. While lighter colors reflect more heat, even darker metal roofs now use reflective pigments to improve performance.
Aesthetic Appeal and Design Options
Your roof plays a major role in your home’s appearance. Whether you lean toward the bold, modern style of metal or the traditional charm of shingles, today’s roofing options offer plenty of ways to match your home’s look.
Metal Roof Styles and Visual Versatility
Metal roofing comes in a wide range of designs, far beyond the old barn tin image.
- Standing Seam roofs feature clean, vertical lines and hidden fasteners, ideal for modern homes, farmhouses, or cabins. Popular colors include charcoal, black, green, and red.
- Metal Shingles and Tiles mimic wood shakes, slate, or clay tile, great for homeowners who want a classic aesthetic with the strength of metal. Products like stone-coated steel offer texture with durability.
- Corrugated and Ribbed Panels give a rustic or industrial look, best suited for rural properties, cabins, or accent areas like porch roofs.
Color Choices
Metal roofs offer an extensive color palette,20 to 40+ standard and custom options, from subtle earth tones to bold hues like deep red, forest green, or matte black. Durable finishes (like Kynar) ensure long-lasting color and minimal fading.
Design Fit and Accents
Metal roofing works well on various home styles, from modern builds and country cottages to Craftsman or even Victorian homes using slate-look metal shingles. Some homes even combine materials (e.g., a metal porch roof with a shingle main roof) for added style. Optional accents like decorative ridge caps or copper highlights can elevate the design further.
Curb Appeal
A thoughtfully chosen metal roof adds strong curb appeal and a premium feel. In areas like Sugarcreek, Ohio, it can blend beautifully with both rural and residential settings, offering timeless charm or sleek contrast, depending on your choice.
Styles and Colors of Asphalt Shingle Roofs
Asphalt shingles may be common, but they offer a surprising range of style and color options, making them a flexible choice for nearly any home.
Shingle Styles
There are two main types:
- 3-tab shingles are flat, uniform, and budget-friendly, though less common in newer homes.
- Architectural shingles are thicker, layered, and more popular today for their visual depth and improved durability.
Color Variety
Shingles come in earthy and neutral tones like gray, brown, green, and slate blue. Each shingle typically blends multiple granule colors, giving the roof a natural, textured look that helps hide aging and wear.
Luxury Shingles
High-end options mimic materials like slate or wood shakes. These thicker, designer shingles offer upscale curb appeal at a lower cost than natural materials, ideal for historic or statement homes.
Home Compatibility
Shingles blend easily into most neighborhoods and are especially well-suited for traditional or historic homes. In HOA or historic districts, they’re often the default approved option, unlike metal, which may face restrictions.
Texture and Finish
With a matte, granular surface, shingles offer a subtle finish that complements classic home styles. Their blended colors help mask dirt, algae, and moss, keeping the roof looking good with minimal maintenance.
Aesthetics & Resale Value
Roof style is all about personal preference. Some homeowners love the bold, modern look of metal, while others prefer the classic, familiar appeal of shingles. Metal can also be used as an accent, on porches or dormers, paired with a shingle main roof that complements the style of your home.
Both options can boost resale value, but metal may stand out more if buyers appreciate its durability. Still, preferences vary by neighborhood, so it’s worth considering what’s typical in your area.
In the end, metal offers striking, long-lasting style, while shingles provide a timeless, versatile look. Choose what feels right for your home.
Installation Process and Complexity
The process of installing a new roof is a major project. Here we’ll compare how the installation of metal vs shingle roofs works and how complex each is.
Professional Installation Requirements
Both metal and shingle roofing ultimately should be installed by professionals for most homeowners’ peace of mind (and warranty protection), but there’s a difference in the level of specialization.
Asphalt Shingle Installation
Almost any licensed roofer or general contractor is familiar with installing asphalt shingles – it’s the bread and butter of roofing. The process involves:
- Tear-off (if it’s a replacement job, the old shingles and underlayment are removed, unless layering over existing shingles, which is generally not recommended).
- Deck prep: Any rotten plywood is replaced, then a layer of roofing felt or synthetic underlayment is rolled out over the wood sheathing.
- Flashing and drip edges: A metal drip edge is installed along the eaves and rakes, and flashing (metal pieces) around things like chimneys or where the roof meets a wall.
- Shingle application: Starting at the bottom edge, shingles are nailed in place in overlapping rows, following a staggered pattern. Valleys and ridges are done with special techniques (weaving shingles or metal valley flashing, etc., and ridge cap shingles on the top).
- Finishing touches: ventilation components like ridge vents, pipe boot flashings, etc., are installed and sealed.
Metal Roofing Installation
While metal roof installation varies by system, the process typically requires more skill, precision, and special equipment than shingle roofing. Here’s a general breakdown:
- Custom Sizing and Cutting
Panels are usually ordered to match the roof’s eave-to-ridge dimensions, but still need to be cut on site for hips, valleys, and angles. This requires precise measuring and tools like metal shears, nibblers, or specialized saw blades to prevent damaging the protective finish. - Panel Handling and Placement
Large panels (often 20 feet or more) must be carefully lifted and placed without bending, buckling, or scratching them. Often, this is a two-person task per panel to ensure proper alignment and handling. - Seaming and Fastening
- Standing Seam Systems: May require mechanical seamers to lock panels together, or they may snap-lock with specialized clips.
- Exposed Fastener Systems: Screws with rubber gaskets are installed at each rib, at precise intervals, and with consistent torque to prevent water intrusion or aesthetic issues.
- Flashing Installation
Flashing around chimneys, skylights, roof edges, and wall junctions must be custom-fabricated and bent to fit precisely. There’s no tolerance for guesswork—unlike shingles, metal cannot be layered to hide imperfections. - Thermal Movement Accommodation
Because metal expands and contracts with temperature, systems may use sliding clips or slotted fastener holes. These must be installed correctly to prevent stress on the panels, fasteners, or seams. - Safety Considerations
Large, sharp-edged metal sheets are dangerous in windy conditions. Proper personal protective equipment (PPE) and fall protection are essential, especially due to the slick surface of metal roofing. - Finishing and Trim Work
Ridge caps, edge trim, pipe flashings, and ventilation components (like ridge vents) must be installed with exactness, sealed properly, and fastened per manufacturer guidelines to maintain warranty coverage.
Weather Resistance and Performance in Ohio’s Climate
Sugarcreek, Ohio, experiences a wide range of weather: heavy winter snow, spring rainstorms, the occasional hail or high winds from summer thunderstorms, and even the rare tornado in Ohio. Your roof is your first line of defense against all of these. Here, we’ll look at how metal and shingle roofs each stand up to extreme weather and what to expect in our local climate.
Metal Roofs and Extreme Weather Conditions
Metal roofs are often touted for their superior performance in harsh weather, including severe weather conditions such as hail, and for good reason. Let’s break down various weather scenarios:
Snow and Ice: Metal roofs perform exceptionally in snowy areas. Their smooth, non-porous surface sheds snow easily, preventing ice dams and refreezing. Snow guards help manage runoff onto walkways.
Wind: With large, secure panels, metal roofs resist wind uplift and meet hurricane standards—many rated for 120+ mph. In gusty regions like rural Ohio, they outperform shingles. Proper edge detailing and a code-savvy installer are essential.
Hail: Most metal roofs have a top-tier Class 4 impact rating, withstanding large hail without failing. While hail can crack shingles, metal (especially steel) may only dent—usually cosmetic and waterproofing remains intact. Insurers often give discounts in hail zones.
Heavy Rain: Both roof types handle rain well if intact. Metal can be louder in uninsulated areas, but in typical homes, sound is minimal—some even find it soothing. In places like Sugarcreek, noise complaints are rare with a proper installation.
Lightning: Metal roofs don’t attract lightning. If struck, they safely disperse energy and won’t catch fire, thanks to their non-combustible nature.
Fire and Heat: Metal roofs resist fire far better than combustible asphalt shingles. They won’t ignite from embers, fireworks, or wildfires, making them a safer choice in any region.
Shingle Roofs and Weather Challenges
Asphalt shingles perform reliably in most environments but have some weaknesses in Midwest regions like Northeast Ohio, Sugarcreek, and Tuscarawas County.
- Wind: Shingles can lift or tear in strong Midwest gusts, especially as they age—leading to frequent post-storm repairs.
- Hail: Can bruise, crack, or strip granules from shingles. Even impact-rated types are more prone to damage than metal.
- Leaks & Ice Dams: Layered design and aging make shingles prone to leaks, especially during ice dams. Metal sheds snow better, reducing this risk.
- Snow Load: Shingles often need heat cables or manual removal. In contrast, metal roofs naturally shed snow.
- Sun & UV: Prolonged sun exposure causes brittleness and granule loss, especially on south-facing areas.
- Moss & Algae: Common in shaded or damp zones—mostly cosmetic, but still potentially damaging. Some shingles now resist algae growth.
- Extreme Weather: Shingles are more likely to fail in tornadoes or derechos. Metal typically stays intact.
- Overall Durability: Shingles handle daily weather but are less reliable in harsh conditions. Metal offers greater longevity and fewer repairs.
Your Roofing Decision, Made Simple
We’ve covered a lot, from cost and durability to energy efficiency, curb appeal, installation, and weather performance. By now, you should clearly understand how metal and shingle roofs compare and which might suit your home best.
Choosing a new roof can feel overwhelming. It’s a major investment and not a decision most homeowners make often. But here’s the good news: both metal and shingle roofs have their advantages, and the “right” choice depends on your home, your budget, and your long-term goals.
If you’re in or around Sugarcreek, Ohio, and still weighing your options, Asbury Roofing & Siding is here to help. With years of hands-on experience installing both roof types, we’re happy to offer honest, personalized advice, no pressure, just practical guidance.
Whatever you choose, a well-installed roof paired with regular upkeep will protect your home for decades to come. Best of luck with your roofing project, and don’t hesitate to reach out if you need a trusted local expert.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is A Metal Roof Noisier During Rain or Hail?
This is one of the most common myths about metal roofs. The reality is, when installed over solid decking with underlayment and insulation, metal roofs are not significantly louder than shingle roofs. Most residential metal roofs are installed over plywood or OSB sheathing with synthetic underlayment, followed by attic insulation and the home’s ceilings. This layered system effectively dampens noise. You’re more likely to hear rain hitting your windows than your roof.
Will A Metal Roof Increase The Resale Value of My Home in Ohio?
Yes, a metal roof can increase your home’s value and resale value. Homebuyers often see metal roofing as a premium upgrade because of its durability, longevity, and energy efficiency. Studies show homeowners can recoup a significant portion of their investment, sometimes 60–70% or more, when they sell. Plus, the modern look of a metal roof can boost curb appeal, which can help your home sell faster and for more.
Are Metal Roofs Prone to Rust?
No, today’s residential metal roofs are engineered to resist rust. Most are made from galvanized steel or aluminum and are coated with protective finishes. These coatings help prevent rust and fading, even in extreme weather conditions. As long as your roof is installed correctly and maintained, rust shouldn’t be a concern.
Can I Install Solar Panels on a Metal Roof?
Absolutely. Standing seam metal roofs are one of the best roofing types for solar panel installation. The raised seams allow for solar panels to be attached without drilling into the roof surface, which preserves the roof’s integrity and warranty.
References
This Old House – Shingles vs. Metal Roof Cost (2025 Pricing) thisoldhouse.com
This Old House – Metal vs. Asphalt Roofing: What’s the Difference? thisoldhouse.com
State Farm Insurance – Pros and Cons of Metal Roofs statefarm.com
Buckeye Metal Roofing – Metal Roofing vs Asphalt Shingles buckeyemetalroofing.com
Stronghold Roofing – How to Protect Metal Panels from Rust strongholdroofing.com
Decra Metal Roofing – Solar and Metal Roofing: What Contractors Need to Know decra.com
Decra Case Study – Why Metal Roofing is Best for Historic Buildings decra.com
