Skip to content 
Whether you need your roof completely replaced or you only need a few minor repairs, it’s important that you work with a high-quality roofing contractor. This is the only way to ensure that the work will be completed properly and that you’ll get the kind of customer service you deserve throughout the process.
One of the best ways to find a good roofer for your project is by considering the ratings and reviews previous customers have left. We’ll try to make that easier for you below by sharing 10 of the best-rated roofing contractors serving the New Philadelphia, Ohio region. We’ll also identify a few of the additional things you’ll want to consider before making a final choice.
The 10 Top-Rated Roofers in New Philadelphia, Ohio
There are a number of different review platforms customers use to rate roofers they’ve hired, so it can be difficult to make apples-to-apples comparisons. One roof contractor may have dozens of reviews on Google, while another may have received most of its reviews on Angi or Yelp.
So, we’ve tried to consider all of the information available and combine that with our own experience in the roofing industry, to identify 10 of the best roofers in New Philadelphia.
1. Asbury Roofing & Siding
Asbury Roofing & Siding is the premier home exterior service contractor serving the New Philadelphia area. Based in Sugarcreek, Ohio, the Asbury Roofing & Siding team provides a comprehensive assortment of services, including not only roof replacement and repairs, but also siding, gutter, window, and door installation, as well as storm damage repairs.
A team that prides itself in offering personalized service, unmatched craftsmanship, and quick response times, Asbury Roofing & Siding has earned positive reviews across multiple platforms. This includes a 5.0-star rating on Google, a 5 out of 5 Facebook rating, and a 4.9 out of 5 on Angi, as well as an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau.
2. RightMark Roofing
A multi-state roofing outfit, RightMark Roofing offers roof repair, replacement, and coating services for commercial clients in several geographic regions, including the New Philadelphia area. It can sometimes be difficult for contractors who focus on commercial clients to earn a large number of reviews, but RightMark has both a 4.8 rating on Google and a 5 out of 5 on Facebook. They’ve also earned an A+ rating from the BBB.
3. L & J Roofing
L & J Roofing doesn’t provide a lot of information about their team or services on their website, and their overall digital footprint is relatively thin, as they don’t appear to have any active social media profiles. Nevertheless, the team has earned a 5.0-star Google rating across 21 different reviews, demonstrating that they’ve certainly treated their previous customers well and provided high-quality roofing services.
4. Premier Roofing & Construction
Specializing in residential, commercial, and even agricultural roofing services, Premier Roofing & Construction is a full-service contractor based in Dundee, Ohio. Providing both shingle and metal roof solutions (as well as gutter and downspout installation), this contractor hasn’t accumulated reviews across very many platforms, but they do have a 5.0-star Google rating and an A+ rating from the BBB.
5. Tango & Gatti
Based in Dover, Ohio, Tango & Gatti is a residential exterior contractor offering window installation, deck construction, and siding services, in addition to roof repair and replacement. Unlike some of the other roofing contractors listed here, Tango & Gatti has ratings on several platforms, including a 4.8 on Google, 4.9 on Facebook, 4.9 on GuildQuality, and 5 on Angi to go along with an A+ from the BBB.
6. Pine Ridge Roofing
Serving all of Northeast Ohio, Pine Ridge Roofing is a roofing and siding contractor based in Strasburg. This contractor has only been in business since 2020, but it has earned quite a positive reputation in only a few short years, including a 5-star Google rating. They’ve also earned an A+ rating from the BBB, which helps to demonstrate a commitment to professionalism and customer service.
7. J&J Roofing
A Tuscarawas-County-based roofing contractor, J&J Roofing boasts a 5-star Google rating and 5 out of 5 ratings on both Facebook and GuildQuality. Specializing in asphalt shingle installation and repairs, J&J Roofing carries out approximately 300 to 350 roofing jobs each year and has relied primarily on word-of-mouth to reach new customers since starting operations in 2000.
8. Apex Metal Solutions
With a 4.9-star Google rating, a 5 out of 5 on Facebook, and a 4.8 HomeAdvisor score, Apex Metal Solutions has earned a very positive reputation with its previous clients. And though the contractor’s name may give the impression that they only provide metal roofing solutions, they’re actually a full-service home exterior business that also installs shingle roofs, solar panels, and siding.
9. World Class Roofing
Licensed in Ohio, West Virginia, and Pennsylvania, World Class Roofing has spent the last 10 years providing top-quality roofing services, completing more than 2,000 jobs, and racking up positive reviews. In fact, this contractor not only has a 5-star Google rating, but also a perfect 5 out of 5 on Facebook, and an A+ rating from the BBB. In addition to shingle roofs, World Class Roofing also provides metal roof installation and repair.
10. Premier Quality Exteriors
Premier Quality Exteriors has only been serving the New Philadelphia area for about 4 years, so they haven’t yet accumulated the sheer volume of reviews that some of the older businesses in our area. However, the reviews and ratings this siding, roofing, and gutter service has earned have been overwhelmingly positive, including a 5.0 on both Google and Yelp, as well as an A+ from the BBB.
Picking a Roofer in New Philadelphia: Other Things to Think About
Ratings and reviews are unquestionably important factors to consider when selecting a roofing contractor, but they’re not the only thing you’ll want to think about. When trying to choose a roofer, be sure to verify that they:
- Are licensed to work in Ohio. To avoid potential code violations, it’s important to select a roofing contractor who is licensed by the State of Ohio and familiar with the regulations surrounding roof repairs and installations.
- Have comprehensive insurance coverage. Insurance — including workers’ compensation insurance — is critical for protecting you from claims, should property damage or injuries occur while the work is being completed.
- Offer solid warranties on materials and workmanship. Most roof material manufacturers offer warranties for product defects, but good roofers provide workmanship warranties covering labor too.
- Provide detailed, written estimates. Pricing transparency is critical during roofing projects, and high-quality contractors will always treat you fairly and offer itemized estimates that include all the project costs.
- Use high-quality roofing materials. Craftsmanship is undeniably important, but so is the quality of materials used to repair or replace a roof, which means that you only want a contractor who uses premium products.
- Have experience with your specific roofing type. It’s always important to select a roofing contractor who has experience with your specific roof type, whether that involves asphalt shingles, metal roofing, or a flat roof.
- Communicate clearly and promptly. Reliable roofers will always keep you informed, answer any questions you have, and make the entire roof repair or replacement process smooth and stress-free from start to finish.
- Maintain a clean and safe job site. Proper site maintenance, cleanup, and safety practices protect your family, property, and workers, and they prevent you from having to pay for cleanup services once the job is complete.
By considering all of these factors along with the ratings and reviews the roofing contractor has accumulated, you’ll have a great chance of hiring the perfect roofer for your project.
Finding the Best-Rated Roofer in New Philadelphia: FAQ
Have additional questions about finding a good roofer in New Philadelphia? We’ve rounded up some of the most common questions homeowners and commercial property managers have and answered them below.
How can you tell a good roofer?
You can identify a good roofer by considering several key factors, including the ratings and reviews the contractor has earned, their experience level, and the quality of materials they use. It’s also important to review previous projects the roofer has completed to see the results they’ve achieved for other customers.
What is the 25% rule for roofing?
The 25% rule in roofing asserts that roofs that have suffered damage to more than 25% of the surface area should be replaced rather than repaired.
How much does it cost to roof a 2,000-square-foot house?
The cost of roofing a 2,000-square-foot house will vary based on a variety of factors, but most projects will cost between $7,000 and $25,000, with the national average hovering around $10,000.
Are roof quotes negotiable?
Some roofing contractors will negotiate the price of a roof repair or replacement, but others will hold firm on the price from the estimate. There’s never any harm in trying to negotiate, but remember to be professional and courteous while doing so and don’t be surprised if your preferred contractor politely declines to reduce the price.
Do you pay roofers before or after installation?
Professional roofers typically require a partial deposit before work begins, but the final balance is typically only paid once the work is complete. Be wary of roofers who require you to pay for the entire project before work begins.
What is the best time of year for roofing?
Roofing work can be completed at any time of year, but fall is generally considered the best time, thanks to the mild temperatures.
Trust Asbury Roofing & Siding for Your Roof Replacement Needs!
There are certainly several high-quality roofers in the New Philadelphia area, but none provide the combination of high ratings, transparent pricing, and industry-leading customer service that Asbury Roofing & Siding does. Whether you need a complete roof replacement or just a simple leak repair, we’ll be happy to provide the roofing solutions you need.
Contact us today to set up your free roof inspection and video report. We’ll outline some of the options available for your roof and provide you with a written estimate for our services.
Sources & References
- Angi – “How to Hire a Roofer: Checklist & Ratings Guide”
Explains how to evaluate roofing contractors using ratings, reviews, licensing checks, warranties, and transparent estimates across major review platforms.
https://www.angi.com/articles/6-tips-choosing-roofing-contractor.htm
